Turn the GitHub integration into a GitHub App
in progress
Patryk Zawadzki
The current integration uses the account of the person that enabled it so in our organization it looks like I'm personally writing a comment under each new pull request. It's also impossible to tell if a task was closed by me or by a ClickUp automation.
Please build a proper GitHub App and use your own App account to perform synchronization tasks.
Log In
L
Logan Stuart
Can this be moved to the integrations category so it properly displays as its current rank of the second highest voted integration issue ever. Not doing this is a massive security/compliance issue and frankly also a business continuity problem.
Anthony Raad
Hey everyone! We're exploring how to enhance your Integration experience using AI, and we want your feedback on what's useful. Please take this 1-minute survey to share your thoughts.
Brendon McCarthy
Anthony Raad To be very direct, AI integration is not a priority if the functionality of the existing integration is sub-par. Please fix the underlying issues first before slapping AI onto of it ;)
Anthony Raad
Brendon McCarthy That's great feedback, Brendon! I hear you, and we still value addressing pain points in the existing integration experience. This work is being explored by a separate team altogether, so it won't impede anything else that's happening by our Integrations team.
C
Charlie Croom
Anthony Raad Underscoring Brendon's point, this seems pretty tone deaf. The AI stuff is fad non-sense. None of that matters if I don't want to use the integration in the first place because it's so arduous and annoying to setup. I understand it's a different team, but that implies the company should be prioritizing resources better so that the fundamentals are sound and can actually support the features-de-jour before working on marketing ploys.
J
Jakub Panik
Is this being still worked on?
Carolyn Tran
With Github integration, the shared github connection doesn't mean shared by definition since no other admin can ad repo to the shared connection.
Feature request: Can we add a permission that would allow others admin users to be able to update and add repo.. Otherwise it would be a bottleneck since only 1 user can add and remove repo with github connection.
k
kettie22
Private GitHub Apps can only be installed on the user or organization account of the app owner. Limited information about the app will exist on a landing page ...
Matthew Pavkov
Agreed with the comments here:
- Permissions are out of line (requiring full code access is unacceptable)
- Author attribution is needed (especially for teams)
Felix Bauer
What's the ETA on the improved GitHub integration Ivan Kanevski?
Ivan Kanevski
Felix Bauer: It's rolling out gradually, in parts.
Lots of underlying infrastructure has already rolled out. We are planning to roll out App Center configuration updates later in the week.
Once that's out, we will be in a position to patch the original issue that started this Canny thread as well as improve the task-level Github experience.
Andrew King
> improve the task-level Github experience
Ivan Kanevski: Do you mean we will be able to sync github issues as clickup tasks? That would be awesome! 🤗
Felix Bauer
Ivan Kanevski bump. When will this happen?
R
Rebecca Julius
Ivan Kanevski is there any update on the main issue that started this? Mainly, that a specific user's account is the one making comments on Github Pull Requests?
j
jose armenta
Ivan Kanevski: Is there an update on the ETA?
Joe Brauckmann
Would also love if the github integration/app didn't have incredibly invasive permissions. We opted for a custom integration via webhooks, flask app, and CU API. Not as clean of a solution but one that protects our repos' privacy.
Ivan Kanevski
in progress
We are currently digging into improving the Github integration. There are a lot of things to improve, and this is at the top of the list.
C
Charlie Croom
Wanted to add to what's been said before. Using a personal account to comment on the Github tickets effectively makes Github useless for that particular person since their automated comments become indistinguishable from real ones.
If you are looking at using Clickup with Github. I would advise looking for another product as the integration is very immature in that respect!
Load More
→